Sophia Critical Thinking Touchstone 4: Contrasting Normative Arguments Guide

Wrapping up Sophia Learning’s Critical Thinking course brings you to Touchstone 4, an exercise in translating everyday debates into standard logical form. Using the provided Microsoft Word template (.doc or .docx), you will break down two opposing viewpoints into clear, structured premises that lead directly to a logical conclusion. To earn full credit, each side of the argument must include at least one normative premise (a moral assumption about what people ought to do) and end with a normative conclusion stating what individuals or institutions should do. Once both arguments are mapped out, you will wrap up the template by answering the required reflection questions thoroughly.

Need Help With Your Standard Form Arguments?

Uncovering hidden moral assumptions and structuring opposing viewpoints into valid standard form can be tricky, especially if formal logic is new to you. If your schedule is packed or you want to make sure your premises and conclusions meet every rubric requirement, SophiaEssays is ready to help. You can get an original Touchstone 4 normative argument assignment that you can turn in with complete confidence. Choose the best of 30+ English native-speaking authors to structure both opposing arguments, pinpoint clear normative premises, and write thoughtful reflection answers so your credits transfer without any delays.

Finishing Sophia Critical Thinking Touchstone 4
Get Your Custom Critique

Touchstone 4: Contrasting Normative Arguments in Standard Form

Overview

What You Will Learn: This Touchstone will give you practice in translating natural language arguments into standard form, with emphasis on the normative premises, that is, the fundamental beliefs about what people ought to do; that shape these opinions.

Why it Matters: By translating normative arguments into standard form, you can find hidden premises, those moral assumptions that lead to better understanding of your own opinions and the opinions of others. Rather than “talking past each other,” you can address these fundamental assumptions.

What You Will Hand In: The completed assignment using the template file below, saved as a Microsoft Word (.doc or .docx) file.

Keys to Success:

  • Hand in original work.
  • Carefully write the set of premises that form two opposing arguments.
  • In each argument, include at least one normative statement, or moral premise, that leads to the conclusion.
  • In each argument, end with a normative conclusion, that is, one that states what people or institutions ought to do.
  • Answer the reflection questions completely.

Helpful Links:

Share your feedback on Touchstones

Instructions

Step 1: View the Example

Open the example of contradictory arguments

Here is an example of two arguments with normative conclusions taking contrary points of view. The normative premises are marked with an asterisk. This serves as an example of what arguments look like in standard form. This topic may not be used for your own Touchstone.

  1. Americans are granted the right to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness as a foundational principle of its founding documents.
  2. Among these rights are bodily autonomy and personal decisions about family planning.*
  3. Forcing a parent to go through an unwanted pregnancy and childbirth violates these principles by taking away their basic right to liberty and long-term pursuit of happiness.*
  4. Forcing a parent to go through an unwanted pregnancy and childbirth also frequently presents a threat to the life of the birth parent.
  5. There is no constitutional or scientific reason to confer personhood on a fetus.
  6. Any opinion on the personhood of fetuses is thus not based on law or science, but a personal moral or religious choice.
  7. The Constitution (Amendment 1) establishes the freedom of religion.
  8. Therefore, any law derived from a religious stance is unconstitutional (from 5-7).
  9. Therefore, pregnant people have the right to terminate a pregnancy for any reason (from 1-4, 8).
  1. It is wrong to kill a human being without justification such as self-defense.*
  2. An unplanned pregnancy may be inconvenient, but only in rare cases does it present a threat to a person’s life.
  3. In no other cases besides abortion do we make it legal to murder people who inconvenience us.
  4. Born children are also inconvenient, but it is not legal for parents to kill them.
  5. In no other cases besides abortion do we make it legal to murder the born children of rape or incest.
  6. A fetus is a viable human being at 24 weeks.
  7. Therefore, except in cases where the pregnancy presents a threat to the birth parent’s life, abortion should be illegal after 24 weeks.

Finishing Sophia Critical Thinking Touchstone 4

Get a 100% original standard form argument assignment you can turn in today

Get Your Custom Critique

Step 2: Download the Template

download

Touchstone 4 Template

Step 3: Complete the Template

The template will take you step-by-step as you select a topic and write two opposing arguments in standard form.

Step 4: Answer the Questions

The template will also ask several questions about your reasoning behind the arguments you wrote. Answer each question completely.

This exercise helps identify the premises behind arguments and test if they logically lead to their conclusions. We hope you find it interesting as well!

Share your feedback on Touchstones


Rubric

 Advanced (100%)Proficient (85%)Acceptable (75%)Needs Improvement (50%)Non-Performance (0%)
Logical Arguments: FormResponse shows understanding of logical arguments. (20%)Both arguments meet all requirements, with notably clear writing and careful sequencing of statements.Both arguments have the minimum number of statements (5). All statements are declarative (make an assertion), and final sentences are normative conclusions. Minor issues may be present.One or both arguments fall short of goal by 1-2 sentences, or 1-2 sentences do not make declarative statements. A normative conclusion is present for each argument.One or both arguments fall short of goal by 3 or more sentences, or 3 or more sentences do not make declarative statements, or final sentence is not a normative conclusion.Argument is not in standard form, or argument falls so short of goal that no credit can be given, or only one argument is provided.
Logical Arguments: Strength/ValidityResponse shows understanding of premises supporting a conclusion. (20%)Both arguments meet all the requirements, with a notably convincing or sound argument.Both arguments have premises that show the conclusion is true or probable and have at least one normative premise to support the conclusion. Minor issues may be present.One or both arguments include 1-2 premises which do not support the conclusion. At least one normative premise supports the conclusion in each argument.One or both arguments include 3 or more premises which do not support the conclusion and/or there is no normative statement to support the conclusion.One or both arguments are absent, in essay form, or are so poorly formed that no credit can be given.
Logical Arguments: AnalysisCorrectly identifies and describes components of a logical argument. Support for premises is included. (10%)Both arguments correctly identify the normative premise and do not mistakenly identify any declarative sentence as normative. The students shows good judgment in which claims need supporting citations and do so with reliable sources.Both arguments correctly identify the normative premises but may mistakenly identify one other statement as normative. The student provides supporting citations for most or all of their claims.Both arguments correctly identify the normative premises but mistakenly identify other statements as normative. The student provides supporting citations for some of the claims but fail to do so with others.Many statements are marked as normative, or the student otherwise seems to not grasp the concept. The student provides no supporting citations for most or all of their claims.Components of argument are not identified as described in the instructions and no support is given for claims. No credit can be given.
Reflection – Key ConceptsAnswers reflection questions thoroughly and thoughtfully, using key concepts from the course. (25%)Demonstrates deep understanding of key concepts in the class with accurate and insightful responses to questions, using the appropriate vocabulary from the tutorials. Supports each answer with specifics where needed. Meets or exceeds recommended length guidelines.Demonstrates good understanding of key concepts in the class with accurate responses to questions, using appropriate vocabulary from the tutorials. Supports each answer with specifics where needed. Meets or exceeds recommended length guidelines. Minor errors may be present.Demonstrates some understanding of key concepts in the class but may lack specifics or detail, and some answers may be inaccurate or insubstantial, or makes only occasional or inappropriate use of the vocabulary from the tutorials. Nearly meets recommended length guidelines.Demonstrates a flawed understanding of key concepts, or answers are so insubstantial that understanding of the concepts cannot be appropriately assessed.No attempt has been made to answer the questions.
Reflection – Critical ThinkingReflects on the learner’s experience of crafting the arguments and overcoming challenges to critical thinking. (15%)Demonstrates thoughtful reflection about the learner’s experience of crafting the arguments and overcoming challenges to critical thinking; includes insights, observations, and/or examples in all responses, and follows or exceeds response length guidelines.Demonstrates thoughtful reflection about the learner’s experience of crafting the arguments and overcoming challenges to critical thinking; includes occasional insights, observations, and/or examples, and follows response length guidelines. More detail could be included.Demonstrates some reflection about the learner’s experience in crafting the arguments and overcoming challenges to critical thinking. Some responses are lacking in detail or insight; primarily follows response length guidelines.Shows limited reflection; the majority of responses are lacking in detail or insight, or are mostly general responses about potential assumptions, biases, or challenges to critical thinking, rather than reflections on the learner’s own experience in crafting the arguments and facing challenges in critical thinking. Some questions are left unanswered or fall short of response length guidelines.No attempt has been made to answer the questions.
ConventionsSubmission follows conventions for standard written English and meets requirements. (10%)There are almost no errors in grammar, punctuation, spelling, and capitalization; all length and formatting requirements are met.There are minor errors in grammar, punctuation, spelling, and capitalization that do not impede readability; length and formatting requirements are nearly met.There are frequent errors in grammar, punctuation, spelling, and capitalization that somewhat impede readability; length and formatting requirements are nearly met.There are consistent errors in grammar, punctuation, spelling, and capitalization that significantly impede readability; length and formatting requirements are not met.Submission does not meet the minimum threshold for points to be awarded.

Charlotte Drummond

She holds an M.A. in Teaching, English Education (Secondary) from Western Governors University. With strong experience supporting online learners, she understands the structure of Sophia courses and the common challenges students face with Challenges, Milestones, and Touchstones. Charlotte works on the courses for them, helping students complete their courses quicker, earn transfer credits, and graduate faster.

Related Articles

Critical Thinking  • November 14, 2026

Sophia Critical Thinking Touchstone 2: Critique an Argument Guide

Moving through Sophia Learning’s Critical Thinking course brings you to Touchstone 2, a 1 to 2 page analytical exercise where ... Read more